|
 American journalist Joe Sharkey, who covered a 2006 plane crash in Brazil between a Boeing 737 (all 154 people aboard the plane died) and a small executive jet in which he was a passenger, faces an onerous civil defamation suit for comments he said were wrongly attributed to him.
On the third anniversary of the accident, which happened on September 29, the Committee to Protect Journalists has called on Brazilian judicial authorities to dismiss the case, which is based on the tenuous claim that the comments insulted the nation of Brazil.
Sharkey, a freelance reporter who contributes regularly to The New York Times and other U.S. outlets, told CPJ that he was served with the complaint on September 16 of this year although the lawsuit was filed in Brazil in 2008.
The plaintiff is identified as Rosane Gutjhar, a resident of Curitiba, the capital of Paraná, in southern Brazil, who claims that Sharkey offended Brazil's honor in comments made on the journalist's blog and in interviews with international media following the crash, according to legal documents reviewed by CPJ.
Gutjhar is asking for a public retraction and 500,000 Brazilian reais (US$ 279,850) in damages, Sharkey said. Gutjhar's suit is based on a provision of Brazilian law that allows private citizens to claim damages for perceived insults against national honor. Such a broad standard for insult is uncommon in the region, CPJ research shows.
Specifically, the plaintiff claims that Sharkey insulted Brazil's dignity by calling it "archaic" and its citizens "idiots." But Sharkey said he did not write the comments cited in Gutjhar's lawsuit. In a letter to CPJ, Sharkey said the quotes cited in the lawsuit can be traced to reader comments published on the Brazilian Magazine Brazzil, which he said were falsely attributed to him.
"We believe that the suit against Joe Sharkey is unfounded as it is based on commentary wrongly attributed to the reporter," said Carlos Lauría, CPJ Americas senior program coordinator. "Brazilian judicial authorities should dismiss this case. Sharkey has the right to report on this tragic accident and voice his opinion on the ongoing investigation."
On September 29, 2006, a mid-air collision killed Gutjhar's husband and 153 other passengers traveling on a Brazilian commercial airliner that crashed with a U.S. business jet at 37,000 feet (11,000 meters) above the Amazon, according to press reports. Sharkey was aboard the business jet with two pilots and four other passengers, all of whom survived after an emergency landing in the jungle, the reporter told CPJ.
According to local and international press reports, Brazilian authorities opened a criminal negligence investigation against the two pilots flying the U.S. business jet. The pilots were detained in Brazil for two months before being allowed to return to the United States, according to news reports.
They are now being tried in absentia. An investigation by the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board pointed to the Brazilian air traffic control system as the probable cause of the crash, according to press reports.
Immediately following the collision, Sharkey reported firsthand for the Times, and gave a series of interviews to U.S. and international outlets as soon as he returned to the United States. He has vigorously criticized Brazilian authorities on his blog and in interviews, characterizing the air traffic control system as very poor.
CPJ research shows that Brazilian businessmen, politicians, and public officials have filed thousands of lawsuits in recent years against news outlets and journalists as a way to strain their financial resources and force them to halt their criticism.
The practice is so common that it's known as the "industry of compensation." The lawsuits are filed in a politicized climate in which lower court judges routinely interpret Brazilian law in ways that restrict press freedom, CPJ has found.
"The case again Joe Sharkey and the onslaught of civil and criminal complaints against Brazilian journalists are unbecoming of a robust democracy such as Brazil," Lauría said. "Brazil must update its defamation laws in a way that protects individual reputations while ensuring a healthy debate of public issues."
 |
Subscribe to this comment's feed
The small, coastal town of Condé is located just a twenty minute's drive from João Pessoa, the capital of Paraíba. The Northeast of Brazil has historically been a place of encounter and mixing between peoples. For millenia groups of indigenous people fished, farmed, migrated and sometimes fought along this large, fertile area. 
The Brazilian diplo-MÁ-cia (bad diplomacy) carries on its accelerated course towards the non-acknowledgment of human rights, although sometimes it takes pleasure in saying that it does precisely the opposite. The visit of Iran's president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, is another example of a diplomatic omission that verges on hypocrisy. 
On July 4, 2006, representatives of Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay met in Caracas to sign the protocol for the entrance of Venezuela into the Southern Common Market (Mercosur). After two and a half years, the protocol was approved by the legislative bodies of Argentina and Uruguay, and as of now it may be only days away from being ratified by the continent's economic megalith, Brazil. 
Some sectors of the fight against AIDS have suggested that Thabo Mbeki, the former president of South Africa, committed genocide through his absence from the fight against the illness in his country throughout his two terms. 
One hundred and eleven years after Brazil abolished slavery, the number of workers deprived of their freedom is still huge. They raise cattle, produce charcoal, sugar cane or timber. Some of them, most undocumented Bolivians, work in basements of small apparel factories in São Paulo and other metropolis. 
On November 7, 2009 a few friends and I had an opportunity to take a look inside a Brazilian jail outside the city of Rio de Janeiro. We were able to take some amateur footage of our experience on video (see link below). It's no surprise, of course, that the typical Brazilian jail lacks some of the functionality of those in North America or Europe, but our experience that day was quite shocking. 
Depletion of the Amazon Rainforest is not a new concern facing environmentalists, biologists, ecologists, and a growing number of the Amazonian indigenous peoples. For decades they have feared for the fate of the world's most biologically diverse and species-rich hothouse. 
Geisy Arruda made history this week in Brazil, but for all the wrong reasons. What began as a poorly planned fashion statement has become a worldwide tale. Geisy decided to wear a pink mini-dress to her private college in São Paulo state, and after that, all hell broke loose. 
The push of vigilante groups in Rio de Janeiro's favelas (shantytowns) in the last three years is the most important and alarming information of the just-released study by the Rio de Janeiro University's Violence Research Center (Nupev-Uerj). 
A dispute over drug trafficking territory in Rio de Janeiro has intensified lately, leaving in its wake unprecedented acts of violence, such as the downing of a police helicopter in the northern zone of the city on October 17. Three policemen died and another two were injured. This event has drawn the attention of the international media, who are raising the issue of public security for the 2016 Olympics to be held in Rio.
Right. I am sure the Brasilian Congress will get on that right away.